The famous Sharktooth Hill Bone Bed near Bakersfield has tantalized the imagination of scientists and laymen alike since it was first discovered in the 1850s. How did a six-to-20-inch-thick layer of fossil bones, gigantic shark teeth and turtle shells three times the size of today’s leatherbacks come to be?

Was this a killing ground for C. megalodon, a 40-foot long shark that roamed the seas until 1.5 million years ago? Perhaps a great catastrophe like a red tide or volcanic eruption led to animal mass-death in the region? Or is this simply the result of Sharktooth Hill being used as a breeding ground for generations of marine mammals throughout the millennia?

A research team consisting of palaeontologists from the United States and Canada are now offering their take on the Bone Bed, suggesting it is not the result of a sudden die-off or a certain predator. Instead, the North American team sees it as a 700,000-year record of normal life and death, kept free of sediment by unusual climatic conditions between 15 million and 16 million years ago.

The research team bases its hypothesis on a new and extensive study of the fossils and the geology of Sharktooth Hill. Roughly 3,000 fossilized bone and teeth specimens found in various museums, including the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County (NHM) and UC Berkeley’s Museum of Paleontology (UCMP), have been scrutinized, and the researchers also cut out a meter-square section of the bone bed, complete with the rock layers above and below.

“If you look at the geology of this fossil bed, it’s not intuitive how it formed,” says Nicholas Pyenson, a former UC Berkeley graduate student who is now a post-doctoral fellow at the University of British Columbia. “We really put together all lines of evidence, with the fossil evidence being a big part of it, to obtain a snapshot of that period of time.”

The existence of a 700,000-year window through which we can catch a glimpse of the past is naturally magnificent news for anyone interested in evolution and Earth’s history.

When the Central Valley was a sea

When the Sharktooth Hill Bone Bed formed between 15,900,000 and 15,200,000 years ago, the climate was warming up, ice was melting and the sea level was much higher than today. What is today California’s Central Valley was an inland sea with the emerging Sierra Nevada as its shoreline.

After closely examining the geology of the Sharktooth Hill area, the research team was able to confirm that it had once been a submerged shelf inside a large embayment, directly opposite a wide opening to the sea.

Several feet of mudstone interlaced with shrimp burrows is present under the bone bed, which is typical of ocean floor sediment several hundred to several thousand feet below the surface. Inside the bone bed, most of the bones have separated joints, indicating that they have been scattered by currents.

“The bones look a bit rotten, as if they lay on the seafloor for a long time and were

abraded by water with sand in it“, says UC Berkeley integrative biology professor Jere Lipps.

Many bones also had manganese nodules and growths on them, something which can form when bones sit in sea water for a long time before they are covered by sediment. According to the team, the most likely explanation for this is that the bones have lain exposed on the ocean floor for 100,000 to 700,000 years while currents have carried sediment around the bone bed. The prevailing climatic conditions at the time have made it possible for the bones to accumulate in a big and shifting pile at the bottom of the sea.

“These animals were dying over the whole area, but no sediment deposition was going on, possibly related to rising sea levels that snuffed out silt and sand deposition or restricted it to the very near-shore environment,” says Pyenson. “Once sea level started going down, then more sediment began to erode from near shore.”

The team discards the breeding-ground hypothesis due to the scarcity of remains from young and juvenile animals. Hungry Megalodon sharks being the main contributors to the bone pile is also unlikely, since few bones bear any marks of shark bites. If the bone bed was the result of mass-death caused by an erupting volcano the absence of volcanic ash in the bed would be very difficult to explain, and the presence of land animals like horses and tapirs that must have washed out to sea make the red-tide hypothesis equally thin.

Amazing remains from the past

The Sharktooth Hill Bone Bed covers nearly 50 square miles just outside and northeast of Bakersfield in California and is one of the richest and most extensive marine deposits of bones in the world. Studied parts of the bone bed average 200 bones per square meter, most of them larger bones. Ten miles of the bed is exposed, and the uppermost part of the bed contains complete, articulated skeletons of whales and seals.

Within the bone bed, scientists have found bones from many species that are now extinct and the bed provides us with invaluable information about the evolutionary history of whales, seals, dolphins, and other marine mammals, as well as of turtles, seabirds and fish. Sharktooth Hill is naturally the sight of some impressive shark findings too, including shark teeth as big as a hand and weighing a pound each.

A small portion of the bone bed was added to the National Natural Landmark registry in 1976 but the rest is in dire need of protection.

A collaborative effort

The research team, who’s study will be published in the June 2009 issue of the journal

Geology, consisted of:

– UC Berkeley integrative biology professor Jere Lipps, who is also a faculty curator in UC Berkeley’s Museum of Paleontology.

– Nicholas Pyenson, a UC Berkeley Ph.D who is now a post-doctoral fellow at the University of British Columbia.

– Randall B. Irmis, a UC Berkeley Ph.D who is now an assistant professor of geology and geophysics at the University of Utah.

– Lawrence G. Barnes, Samuel A. McLeod, and Edward D. Mitchell Jr., three UC Berkeley Ph.D’s who are now with the Department of Vertebrate Paleontology at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County.

According to University of Washington geologist and tsunami expert Jody Bourgeois, the idea that chevrons – a type of large U- or V-shaped formations found along certain coasts – were caused by mega-tsunamis is pure nonsense.

The term chevron refers a special type of vast dunes shaped a bit like the stripes on soldier’s uniform. They can be anything from hundreds of meters to a kilometre in length and can be seen in places such as Egypt, the Bahamas, Madagascar, and Australia.

Some scientists have suggested that a possible explanation for these mysterious stripes is mega-tsunamis caused by asteroid or comet impact. According to this school of thought, the chevrons may be deposits left by gigantic tsunamis 4,800 to 5,000 years ago, tsunamis that might have been up to 10 times larger than the earthquake-caused Indian Ocean tsunami of December 2005. Due to the location of known chevrons, the Indian Ocean has been suggested as ground zero for the comet or asteroid impact.

Bourgeois, a professor of Earth and space sciences who has studied earthquakes and tsunamis in various parts of the world, does not agree. According her, the chevrons are not lined up the way you would expect from deposits caused by gigantic waves. Many of the chevrons on Madagascar are for instance parallel to the coastline, instead of perpendicular to the shore.

Models created by Bourgeois’ colleague Robert Weiss, assistant professor of geology at

Texas A&M University, show that deposits formed by gigantic tsunamis would point in the same direction as the waves were travelling when the reached land, which is mostly perpendicular to the shore.

“And if it really was from an impact, you should find evidence on the coast of Africa too, since it is so near,” Bourgeois explains.

The computer model generated actual conditions for a tsunami which made it possible to use the model to explore the effects of an asteroid or comet hitting the part of the Indian Ocean suggested by mega-tsunami chevron proponents. According to the model, the gigantic waves would approach land at a 90-degree orientation to the chevron deposits.

“The model shows such a tsunami could not have created these chevrons, unless you have some unimaginable process at work,” Bourgeois says.

Bourgeois and Weiss have used satellite images from Google Earth to get close-up looks at chevrons in different locations. Chevron are most common in coastal regions but you can find quite a lot of them in semiarid inland areas as well.

Bourgeois and Weiss wrap up their paper, which can be found in the May issue of the journal Geology, by stating that “the extraordinary claim of ‘chevron’ genesis by megatsunamis cannot withstand simple but rigorous testing. […] There are the same forms in the Palouse in eastern Washington state, and those are clearly not from a tsunami.”