Carbon and aquariums

Carbon use in the aquarium seems to be misunderstood. It seems like almost every book recommends it. Most fishkeepers use it. Every filter has it either built in or available as a separate media. However, it is completely unnecessary for constant use.

Carbon has certain functions in the aquarium. The main one is removing medications. Many medications are very strong and harmful and if not used properly or left in the tank too long can end up causing more harm than good. Because of this it is a good idea to use carbon to remove medications after treatment is complete.

There are a few other benefits of carbon. They are mainly in the removal of odor and discoloration. However, these things should not be an issue at all if enough water changes are being done. At this point it would simply be ‘if it can help, why not use it?’ That is where the other issues come in.

Carbon is not selective. It removes a lot of different chemicals whether they are good or bad. Some of these are trace elements and micronutrients. These are vital for the proper physiological function of fish, plants, and invertebrates. When these nutrients are removed it can lead to many physiological dysfunctions in the organisms. One possible result in some species is Head and Lateral Erosion (HLLE). HLLE may not include erosion of the lateral line. Generally the symptoms are shallow, wide pits on the head, sometimes also on the lateral line. As the condition progresses it can cause the loss of a lot of tissue and can result in the death of the fish.

I believe that many other species have other problems that are simply not as easily observable as HLLE. What we see as a three year old tetra dying of ‘old age’, some recent change in the tank, or simply unknown causes may actually be the result of a physiological dysfunction caused by a poor diet and/or nutrients being removed by carbon. If the carbon removes these nutrients then the fish can’t use them. This can lead to these unseen internal problems. Since almost no fish have necropsies performed there is no way of knowing if this is true or, what I believe is more likely, how bad the problem is. We know from human health that most problems are internal. The fish cannot tell us that anything is wrong and we cannot detect almost any problems until there are obvious external symptoms. This limits us to relatively few problems being detectable.

There have been cases of HLLE where the only change needed was the removal of carbon. In these cases the HLLE developed while carbon was being used. Sometimes other treatments were attempted and either had no effect or did not fully solve the problem. When the carbon was removed the HLLE went away. In some cases the carbon was returned and immediately following the return of the carbon the HLLE returned as well.

As if this wasn’t enough, most carbon is not effective after a certain period of time. The quality of the carbon is a major factor in how long the carbon will be effective. In addition, the amount of chemicals in the water that will be removed will also affect the lifespan of carbon. In general high quality carbon will last from two to four weeks. Most people do not change their carbon frequently enough, so for at least part of the time it is in the filter it is not providing any benefit anyways.

In summary carbon is an unnecessary and even harmful media that does not need to be used in the aquarium except for short-term applications such as removing medications. When choosing a filter pick one with customizable media that do not require you to use carbon. Avoid those that provide hybrid cartridges that include carbon built in to mechanical media. When using customizable filters use more biological media in place of the carbon.

Didn't find the info you were looking for? Ask your question in our Aquarium forum !
Our knowledgeable staff usually responds to any question within 24 hours

Other Aquarium Articles

Aquarium Cycling - A guide on how to cycle your aquarium.
Aquarium Lighting - Learn the basics of aquarium lighting
Breeding Fish - Overview of How To Breed Tropical Fish
Beginner fish - Great Beginner Fish for the Beginner Aquarist
Bad beginner fish - Horrible Beginner Fish for the Beginner Aquarist
The beginners tank - A guide to your fist aquarium
Cleaning your filter - Basic filter management
Carbon and aquariums - Information on the effects of using carbon in your aquarium.
Cycling - A guide to aquarium cycling and how it works.
Don’t trust the staff in the fish store! - A text about why you shouldn't alway trust your fish store.
Dry and Rainy Seasons in the Tank - A detailed account of how to simulate seasons in aquariums
Electrical Safety and Aquariums - How to prevent electrical accidents.
Filtration pro and cons - thoughts about filtration
Fry Growth rate - Thoughts on how to optimize growth in fry.
Fish keeping for beginners - An introduction for beginners.
Aquarium Filtration- Llists and describes the different methods of aquarium filtration, and then discusses their benefits and drawbacks.
Finding the Triggers - Information about how to find breeding triggers in different fihs species.
Fry Savers - Information about fry savers and how to construct fry savers.
How to Buy Healthy Fish - A gew tips on choosing healthy fish.
Making a Pebble Cave - A guide on how to make your own pebble cave for your fish.
Modifying Water Chemistry - A technical article about modifying hardness, alkalinity and pH.
Optimizing Growth of Fishes - The factors affecting fish growth - some may be manipulated, others not.
Setting up a tropical freshwater aquarium - Detailed guide on how to setup a freshwater aquarium..
Reverse Osmosis and aquariums - RO is a way to get very pure water in which fish such as dicus and neon tetras can breed and raise their fry.
Safe Rock and Wood Aquascaping - How to make sure that the materials you use in your aquascaping are aquarium safe.
Selecting Community Tank Fish - A guide that will help you choose the right fish for you based on tank size and experience level.
Setting Up A New Aquarium - Help beginners setup their first aquarium
Slime coat - Protecting your fishes vital slime coat
Snails in Aquariums - The biology of snails. Their advantages and disadvantages in an aquarium. How to keep them in check.
Amazon Biotope Aquarium - How to set-up, stock and maintain an aquarium that replicates the Amazon watershed.
Wall mounted aquariums - Information about Wall mounted aquariums
Water chemistry in the aquarium - Hardness, alkalinity and pH are discussed technically, from a chemistry point of view.
Water Chillers - Introduction to water chillers.