Results 11 to 20 of 40
10-10-2013, 04:45 PM #11
I do notice the site has stickies for both fish and fishless cycles. I have patience (trying to teach that to the kids) just wondering thoughts on both. I know there is a greater chance of killing off the fish in the fish based cycle. Depending on the types you get or trying to many at once.
It is advised alot here on the AC to have twice as much filtration for your tank than the tank size...a 37 gallon would require at least 74 gallons worth of filtration...why don't you see if your LFS has an AquaClear 75 or even 80 gallon HOB (hang on back) filter?. I use one rated for 30 gallons (AC30) on a 10 gallon tank, no problem whatsoever with too much water flow, it is adjustable.....nice little filters, reasonably priced (usually)...see if they'll take the Whisper filter back and credit you toward an AquaClear...
10-10-2013, 05:24 PM #12
Oh yeah it is also nice to get a filter with adjustable flow. For example, the AquaClear (we really aren't sales people, we just like the product!) has the ability to adjust how much of its output goes to the tank, and route some of it back through the media. In theory you don't lose filtration but you do decrease flow.
I guess instead of just recommending a brand, I'll say the two most important features in a HOB are the ability to change individual pieces of media (not one cartridge - this will also save you money in the long run), and adjustable flow.
10-10-2013, 05:56 PM #13
Before you start wasting money on equipment you don't need, take some time to reflect on what fish you intend (the water parameters will help with this), and then find the filter that will best work for the fish and tank.
Having more filters is not a benefit. All this means is that you are moving more of the water around more, but this does nothing with respect to making the water "more" clean or clear for that matter. Think of filters like medication; all you need is what will do the job...any more and you will have problems.
The most effective filtration is that which is suited to the tank and fish load.
Byron.Byron Hosking, BMus, MA
Vancouver, BC, Canada
Something we all need to remember: The fish you've acquired was quite happy not being owned by you, minding its own business. If you’re going to take it under your wing then you’re responsible for it. Every aspect of its life is under your control, from water quality and temperature to swimming space. [Nathan Hill in PFK]
10-10-2013, 06:47 PM #14
I checked my LFS for those other filters you were suggesting and they don't carry them or any other place in town for that matter. With me living in the sticks I went ahead and paid the $5 more for the next level higher which is rated for the 30-60 gallon capacity to get me started which is still an improvement over the one that barely met the rating according to the box. The only other brand they had that was for larger tanks was Marineland or something like that but the model was to long for my tank as it would not fit due to the cross bar in the tank.
So my plans for tonight are to get my gravel & decorations rinsed.
Get the tank filled and get the heater in.
Then hopefully get the water to start warming and filter turned on.
How long should I wait for the water before I start the cycle process? I can do the fish food method for now otherwise this weekend I could make it to the local hw store to grab a small bottle of ammonia along with some water testing equipment from the LFS. I assume the drip test kits are the better avenue vs strips.
10-10-2013, 07:12 PM #15Senior Member Red tailed catfish
- Join Date
- Dec 2010
10-10-2013, 07:26 PM #16
10-11-2013, 03:16 AM #17
Ok I managed to get my checklist for tonight done. The filter is running and the heater on as well. I did notice that it was a bit cloudy as I filled it up , but it has cleared up a lot. Some of that I attribute to the tap water itself I think. I do also have small pockets of bubbles on the interior of the tank along the glass and in the brief spots where the water filled to in between the bucket pours as I filled it up.
I got the temperature on the water heater set to 79 degrees roughly for the time being with an ambient air temperature of 74 degrees. During the winter we usually turn it down to 70 degrees on the heat but that shouldn't be an issue as the temp of the tank when it comes time to get the fish I believe for most species 75-78 degrees so I can turn it down a bit before getting the fishies in the tank.
Tomorrow I plan on getting some ammonia and a tester to kick start the cycle process.
10-11-2013, 04:59 AM #18
Had a look at your water test. I bet that water doesn't even taste very nice.
Anyway, forget about most Amazon species in that stuff. Livebearers should work well though as would Zebra danios. . Another option is a tanganyikan setup. http://www.cichlid-forum.com/article...cutter_29g.php for example.
10-11-2013, 10:58 PM #19
So I have a couple setbacks...
1) For the life of me no store in my town sells actual ammonia in any quantity. They all either have detergents or fragrances in them so a no go for that. I would either have to find someplace online and hope its the correct kind, find a different way to cycle the tank, or wait until the next time I can make it to the larger city to the south of my (about an hour drive) which will probably be next weekend sometime.
2) The heater I bought is defective. it turns on briefly and then off. So trying to see if it was the thermometer reading the wrong temp or the heater. so I crank it up about 9 degrees. It turns on about 4 minutes later. This time only stayed on for about 5 minutes and shut off again. So I will go exchange it for a new one tomorrow.
but for the cycling options what other fishless options are there?
10-12-2013, 02:47 AM #20
It's exciting to get and set up a new tank and want to start stocking quickly. But one thing I learned along the way was that patience will make your experience much better. I would wait until you can get the right kind of ammonia you need for cycling. You can still set up the tank and decorate it the way you want and at least have something you've created that's nice to look at while waiting for fish.
Use the time it takes to cycle for researching the fish you're interested in, maybe go window shopping at the LFS, but resist any urges to buy something until the tank is ready. A lot of your decisions will depend on what is readily available to you unless you are willing to have fish shipped. That can be a more expensive option and one I have only had to do once. But it opens up the possibilities.