Thread: pros and cons of dirted tanks?
03-17-2013, 12:34 PM #11
I don't blame you on the free shipping bit I'm sure they'll return it. I would mix a small sand/Eco batch first before to see if you like the look. IMO for depth I would have done the first layer with sand at a grade from high to low in the front and then cap that with the Eco while leaving a small gap between the sand and glass in front you can fill with Eco complete. Looking forward to seeing what you do with it.
03-17-2013, 02:18 PM #12
For future reference I use safe t sorb from tractor supply. $4.99 for 40 lbs. My plants do great in it. It is 100% fillers earth.Mike
55g Freshwater | Rena XP3 | Aqueon 55 | Hydor 300w Inline Heater|6 Black Skirt |5 Serpae Tetras |5 Red Eye Tetras | 3 Otto Cats | Planted | STS Substrate
72g Bowfront | Custom Built Coast to Coast Overflow and 20g Sump | 250w Aqueon Pro Heater | Planted | STS Substrate | 3 Zebra Danios | 3 Cardinal Tetras | 2 Veil Angels | 3 Otto Cats
03-17-2013, 03:32 PM #13
Biggest cons for me were the initial algae bloom and not being able to uproot something without clouding the water (though this isn't much of a problem as the substrate matures)
The biggest pro was how well my plants did in it, and how long the substrate lasted without having to fertilize.
03-17-2013, 04:16 PM #14
Disadvantage to me was moving the tank or pulling out plants and replanting them. When I move a tank, I like to remove the substrate, give it a good rinsing out and replace it. You can't do that with soil. You do not need soil to plant a tank heavily, either. A good plant substrate will do the trick.