Ooops my mistake ha. I agree with you, either one would be great but for me i think having a school of neons would provide more interest for me personally. Since you have experience with a shrimp and snail CUC can you suggest numbers and types for me please?, i looking to have at the most 8 neon in my 10g tank and want an effective crew to help keep the tank stable. I will also have some java moss with another plant but not sure which one yet.