Aquarium Forum
 


Menu
  · Tropical Fish Home
· Fish News
· Aquarium Forum
· Calculators
· Equipment reviews
· Free Aquarium Ebook
· Feedback
· Link to us
· Photo gallery
· Plant species
· Tropica Plant DB
Tropical fish species
· By Common name
· By Scientific name
Tropical Marine fish
· By Common name
· By Scientific name

_________________
  ...

Articles
  · African Cichlids
· Algae Control
· Aquarium Decoration
· Aquarium Resources
· Aquatic Plants
· Barb Fish
· Betta Fish
· Breeding Fish
· Catfish
· Central American Cichlids
· Cichlids
· Clownfish
· Corals
· Corydoras Catfish
· Discus Fish
· Dwarf Cichlids
· Fish Diseases
· Frogs and Turtles
· Goby Fish
· Goldfish
· Gourami
· Invertebrates
· Jellyfish
· Killiefish
· Lake Victoria Cichlids
· Livebearers
· Malawi Cichlids
· Marine Aquariums
· Marine Aquarium Fish
· Other Fish
· Pleco
· Predatory Fish
· Photography
· Pond Fish
· Responsible Fish Keeping
· Rainbow Fish
· Shark Fish
· South American Cichlids
· Tanganyika Cichlids
· Tetra Fish
· Tropical Fish Food

User Tag List

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 11 to 17 of 17
  1. #11

    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Saskatchewan, Canada
    Posts
    20,090

    Awards Showcase

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    T.G.I.F.! - Slaphppy7   Chocolate always makes a body better.  Glad you're on the ment - fishmommie   Here's to a quick recovery my friend. - mommy1   Happy Holidays. - gadget228   Have a Candy cane ;-) Merry Christmas - steeler58   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    Could you.... Yes

    Should you.... No


    I can go to a fast food restaurant and for the next 2 or 3 years eat nothing but greasy burgers and frys morning noon and night. I would still look and act healthy, right up until the time I developed health problems from improper diet.

    An argument can be made that my analogy might be a little on the dramatic side, but my point remains the same.

    You can be lucky for quite some time, but at some point you will have to pay the piper
    If you take your time to do the research FIRST, you can successfully set-up and keep ANY type of aquarium with ease.
    "Not using a quarantine tank is like playing Russian roulette. Nobody wins the game, some people just get to play longer than others." - Anthony Calfo
    Fishless Cycle Cycling with Fish Marine Aquarium Info [URL="http://saltwater.aquaticcommunity.com/"]

  2. #12

    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Location
    Europe
    Posts
    4,226

    Awards Showcase

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    Merry Christmas! - ~firefly~   Merry Christmas - mommy1   Merry Christmas! - Slaphppy7   For Your 33 Gallon. Happy Holidays! - Taurus   Happy New Year! - jeffs99dime   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    Quote Originally Posted by Cliff View Post
    Could you.... Yes

    Should you.... No


    I can go to a fast food restaurant and for the next 2 or 3 years eat nothing but greasy burgers and frys morning noon and night. I would still look and act healthy, right up until the time I developed health problems from improper diet.
    Going to be a lot sooner than 2 years Cliff. ;-)

    I still think setting up a shrimp bowl is a good idea for anyone interested in learning how plants actually interact in an eco system.

  3. #13

    Join Date
    May 2012
    Posts
    698

    Awards Showcase

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    ¸.·´¯`·.´¯`·.¸¸.·´¯`·.¸> - korith   No Message - Northerly   thanks for all your help - fishmommie   Merry Christmas - KingFisher   Merry Christmas! - fishmommie   
    HIV/AIDS - Indian Woods Angels   Childhood Cancer - Indian Woods Angels   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    I am going with yes. The system would have to remain absolutely closed and tightly contained. There could be no intervention. You could not add anything into the system nor take anything out. Evaporation could not be allowed to occur. Within this system all things would eventually find balance, could this system satisfy visually our expectations of a successful keeping of an aquarium ? Possibly not. Could this system find it's own balance and find a way to sustain itself on those items closed within itself, yes. Even through what might be perceived as a crash or a catastrophe we would have to have patience and let the system show us it's next phase. Even if it consumed all of it's vital elements and placed them into vegetation or into substrate we would have to see what the cycle shows us and be patient towards how the system would balance. Our natural world has many habitats that we would consider to completely crash each year in a seasonal shift. These places look so remote or so far gone that they magically transform back into bloom.

    A better question might be: Could we be patient enough to allow for the existence of a closed system?

  4. #14

    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Jacksonville, FL
    Posts
    4,966

    Awards Showcase

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    Here's to the holidays! - Slaphppy7   Happy holidays! - rebecca_finny   Merry Christmas (Santa Loves Pie) ;-) - Taurus   Happy Christmas! - Slaphppy7   Good to see you here again... - Slaphppy7   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    I would maintain that for the benefit of the floura and fauna of the tank that you continue waterchanges if you are an aquarist. We could swim in a pool filled with urine, and some would evaporate, if we topped it off with urine it would become more condensed and so on and so forth. Same with the fishes excrements. Even with propper planting, not everything is churned over. There are discus tanks that do 1 a month of 25% who maintain reffugiums to remove nitrates. Such tanks can be sustained but even by said owners it doesnt allow for "optimal" conditions.

    You could go years without changing the water in your tanks and continuously add the topoff amnt. Without actual maintenence, you will find less than optimal conditions on a depleting scale.

  5. #15

    Join Date
    May 2010
    Location
    Glen Arm. MD
    Posts
    2,634

    Awards Showcase

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    Happy Christmas - MuckyFish   thanks for advising on vegetables for my kribs! so here is a discus - ScottishFish   You help a lot - PhillipOrigami   For the bank account, and thx for the rep - Cliff   beautiful discus! - Crispy   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    Impossible without an algae scrubber - the nitrates will build up and become toxic; it would take a high ratio of plants to fish to allow 'a closed system' to work. Minerals as some have pointed out would need to be added.
    Knowledge is fun(damental)

    A 75 gal with eight Discus, fake plants, and a lot of wood also with sand substrate. Clean up crew is down to just two Sterba's Corys. Filters: continuous new water flow; canister w/UV, in-tank algae scrubber!! Finally, junked the nitrate removal unit from hell.

    For Fishless cycling:http://www.aquaticcommunity.com/aqua...ead.php?t=5640

  6. #16

    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Location
    Seattle, WA USA
    Posts
    21

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    Quote Originally Posted by ijankrom View Post
    Listening to a podcast a listener asked a hypothetical question.

    "If a home aquarium is large enough, bioload low enough, and filtering is strong enough, would it be possible to operate a aquarium without completing water changes?"
    The question itself presents several a priori problems:
    1. What is the purpose of a mechanical filter in a closed system?
    2. Are you assuming no addition of elements to the system (including oxygen, carbon)?
    3. Are you assuming no energy transfer (e.g. from heat dissipation, heat absorbed through the electrically powered mechanical filter)?
    4. Related to #2, you would have to assume a natural food chain is established in that closed ecosystem such that the fish will find the food they need within the system, otherwise you're adding elements (nitrogen, carbon, etc) to your system and it, thus, cannot be considered a closed system. It would be a system of increasing nitrogen and carbon source, in whatever elemental form they may be. In that case, the question is non-sequitur.

    I speculate that an equilibrium will be established eventually in a perfectly closed system. That equilibrium, however, will very likely not contain live fish as we know it. As the dead fish decompose and become part of the nitrogen and carbon cycle, I'm sure a new balance of much smaller and/or simpler life forms (like single celled organisms) will emerge.

  7. #17

    Join Date
    Aug 2012
    Location
    in rsa
    Posts
    204

    Latest gifts & ribbons:

    【ツ】 - korith   

    Default


    0 Not allowed!
    nature itself does provide an answer with dams that only get rain water to replenish the water, so why not something smaller enough. A better question is how much money would such a system cost to build, would it run of electricity and how much would you are you willing to spend on construction. My answer is yes. Properly researched and built with only rain water to top up the tank and if you had a big enough piece of land to do it. Science and technology is already years ahead of what we can comprehend all ready, we have more information at our fingertips than our parents.

    just look at our hobby itself how far it has progressed in a hundred years
    we are all on a journey.
    Apparently there is nothing that cannot happen today.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •