Sump on reef?

[DaveS]

I have been reading of reef tanks that use LR and powerheads with no extra filtering. Please help me to understand why some choose to add a sump to their reef. Wouldn't it compete with the LR for nutrients? or is it used when the reef has high fish bioload?

[Halelorf]

Sumps are used for extra water volume, hiding equipment from the main tank like heaters and skimmers so there is more room in the show tank. Also you can have things like refugiums and coral frag areas. Sumps won't compete with the tank LR as there is usually live rubble rock in them or macroalgae. Here is a link that explains benefits and what they are etc.

[Only Registered Users Can See Links.]

[DaveS]

OK. I am thinking that a sump may not be worth it for me. I can fit a 20g under my stand but it isn't significant extra volume and I can't fit my protein skimmer in it. I couldn't fit enough LR in it to compare with my main tank. The other benefits would be nice, though.

[Fishguy2727]

The trend is leaning towards the best use for sumps being as refugiums as well as a place to put the skimmer (improperly adjusted skimmers can overflow, if they are hanging on the back of the tank this can be a huge problem) and other equipment. They are quickly not being associated with what they used to be: wet/dry filtration.

[spudbuds]

How big of a display are you going to have such that an extra 20g wouldn't be beneficial? Just getting the equipment out of the display made it worth it for me. The extra water volume and refuge was a nice bonus. It is really nice not to have to dig around in the display when you need to do maintainence on the equipment.

- Bill

[DaveS]

How big of a display are you going to have such that an extra 20g wouldn't be beneficial?
125g. Well, 20g would be beneficial, I'd have to agree.

Just getting the equipment out of the display made it worth it for me.
<excuse me while I think aloud> :c2:
My tank is not drilled, so I'd have to add an overflow and a return pipe, but on the other hand I could do away with one of the powerheads in the tank. I wouldn't have room for any real amount of LR in the sump, but I could do away with the heaters from the tank. I can remove the skimmer supply pipes from the tank, keep the water levels steady in the main tank and do easier water changes. I could even try a DSB.

LOL. It seems mainly for convenience and playing, but the more I think about it.......:18:

[spudbuds]

You have a 125g tank, but can only fit a 20g in the stand? Do you have any pics of the stand?

I bet someone in a local reef club could help you drill the tank. If not, a siphon overflow would work.

- Bill

[ILuvMyGoldBarb]

Well, you sound like you are in the situation I was in. My 125 is not drilled however I do have a Continuous Siphon Overflow and a 20gal long as my sump. I intend to upgrade at some point, I just need to find a tank that has the right dimensions. My stand is funny as well. Lengthwise I can fit a 55 but the height does not work. A 40gal breeder fits with the height and length but not in width. It is well worth it to add the sump though. If just for the added volume it is worth it because that extra water volume does help make it easier to keep the tank stable.

[Tigerbarb]

I had never thought about how a sump would increase water volume. Looks like I will be adding a 10-20g sump to my 20, getting more live rock, and adding more fish.

[ILuvMyGoldBarb]

What species of Dwarf Angel are you thinking about Tigerbarb? There's really only one that would be ok in your tank and that is the African Flameback.

[Tigerbarb]

I googled the african flameback, and it looks great. Flameback it is.

[unleashed]

I had never thought about how a sump would increase water volume. Looks like I will be adding a 10-20g sump to my 20, getting more live rock, and adding more fish.

Just because you are increasing the water volume for the total system, doesn't mean you are increasing the swimming room. I would never add a dwarf angel to any 20g tank, unless, like gold barb stated, the flame back. However, I still do not think that it is fair to place such an active fish in a tank less than 30g

[Tigerbarb]

I agree, and my tomato clown will soon outgrow my tank. If I somehow do get the flameback, I'd want atleast 50 lbs of rock.(atleast 20 lbs tufa rock)